10 Highly Controversial Statistics From The Culture Wars

They contend that law is a initial misadventure of war, and a enlightenment wars are no exception. Often, though, a genocide isn’t deliberate. With any rarely emotive issue, it can be formidable to arrange a contribution from a theories, a tough law from a exaggerations. The following theories all use genuine information to strech their argumentative conclusions. Whether we find their arguments impressive is adult to you.

10 1 In 3 Men Would Potentially Commit Rape


In 2015, a biography Violence and Gender published a intolerable article. A tiny investigate had reported that scarcely one in 3 college organisation would rape a lady if they suspicion they could get divided with it.

The statistic captivated substantial attention, not slightest given a respondents customarily pronounced that they would rape a lady if a emotive word “rape” was blank from a question. From a representation distance of 86 men, 32 percent pronounced they would “use force” to obtain sex from a woman.

On a other hand, customarily 14 percent were peaceful to contend that they would “rape” a lady if there were no consequences. The researchers theorized that intensity rapists have a ability to see their possess actions in a kinder light, permitting them to dedicate their crimes though pangs of conscience. In light of campus rape problems, a investigate was reported widely.

Some experts took emanate with a methodology, arguing that it drew fake conclusions. The investigate authors used a five-point scale for their questions on rape, where 1 meant “very unlikely” and 5 meant “very likely.”

Those who answered with a 1 were deliberate to have pronounced they would not use force to have sex with a woman. Those who answered with 2–5 were deliberate to have pronounced they would.

Critics argued that this was false and that customarily those who answered with a 4 or 5—a low percentage—should have been enclosed in a argumentative “one in three” figure.

9 40 Percent Of Domestic Violence Victims Are Male


Domestic attack is customarily seen as an emanate that affects women. That’s given it is so absolute to learn that organisation make adult 40 percent of domestic attack victims. This statistic turns a preconceptions on their heads and creates a intolerable indicate about abuse and gender.

The statistic initial came to inflection in 2010 given of a debate by UK men’s rights organisation Parity. After examining information from a British Home Office and a British Crime Survey, they found that organisation done adult on normal 40 percent of a victims of domestic attack in a years 2004–09.

In some years, it was as high as 46 percent. In some, it was as low as 38 percent. Supporters of a statistic disagree that it highlights a genuine problem.

But not everybody agrees that a figure tells a whole story. The arch executive for Women’s Aid has argued that there are opposite definitions of domestic violence. While organisation make adult 40 percent of victims in one-off cases, women are some-more expected to humour mixed incidents over a prolonged duration of time. In cases with 4 or some-more incidents, women make adult 89 percent of victims.

The statistic also caused some debate given many masculine victims of abuse are in same-sex relationships. Women’s groups argued that Parity was therefore wrong to advise that women frequently abuse men.

8 Women Are Just As Likely To Abuse A Partner As Men


In 1975, a National Family Violence Survey by dual sociologists done an engaging discovery. On questions about possibly they had ever strike a spouse, women and organisation replied affirmatively in roughly equal numbers. They also reported removing strike in equal numbers.

Follow-up surveys set out to learn if a women were behaving in self-defense. But again, identical numbers of organisation and women certified to starting a quarrel and throwing a initial punch.

In a 2010 article, one of a authors of a strange investigate resolved from these statistics that women have identical motives for domestic attack as men. Namely, control and coercion. Supporters of a investigate contend that this demonstrates that women are as able of abuse as men.

Others have argued that a researchers’ methodology was flawed. Their papers used a Conflict Tactics Scale (CTS) as a approach to magnitude insinuate violence. CTS has been criticized for not measuring things like duress or pacifist forms of abuse and for withdrawal out passionate assaults. Critics also contend that it doesn’t count attack by ex-partners. So women who are assaulted in punish attacks are not counted in a statistics.

7 Right-Wing Terror Is Deadlier Than Islamist Terror


Since 9/11, terrorism competence have spin a biggest hot-button subject in America. Fairly or unfairly, it is now seen by some as synonymous with “radical Islam.”

Hence a startle that accompanied a New York Times essay on militant beliefs in mid-2015. The journal claimed that an investigate of apprehension attacks on US dirt in a post-9/11 epoch showed that worried extremists had claimed some-more lives than Islamists.

The sum came from a Washington investigate hospital called New America. From Sep 12, 2001, until mid-2015, they found that 74 Americans had died in apprehension attacks. Of those people, 48 were murdered by worried extremists and 26 by Islamic extremists. Following a San Bernardino shooting, a series of murders by Islamic extremists jumped to 40 from 26.

The New York Times essay also remarkable that a series of attacks carried out by worried extremists was 19, compared to 7 by Islamic extremists.

The difficulty of worried extremists includes white supremacists, neo-Nazis, “patriot” militias, and emperor citizens. Sovereign adults do not commend or follow orthodox laws during a federal, state, or internal level.

Some people have argued that these statistics are dubious given they do not embody a genocide fee from 9/11, one of a biggest events in American history. Once a 9/11 deaths are added, a contingency change dramatically. They have also forked out that a smaller series of Muslims than right-wingers in a US race means that particular Muslims are statistically some-more expected to rivet in apprehension attacks.

6 1 In 5 US Women Have Been Raped


In 2010, a CDC began a plan famous as a National Intimate Partner Violence Survey. One of a beginning reports came with a intolerable title figure. Up to one in 5 American women reported that they had been raped in their lifetimes.

Even some-more had gifted some form of neglected passionate contact. Approximately 44 percent of women and 23 percent of organisation had suffered some form of passionate violence.

The CDC subsequently identified passionate attack as a vital health emanate in complicated America. Their consult information came from 12,000 interviews conducted in both English and Spanish and overwhelmed many vital secular groups. It was deliberate to be thorough.

Nevertheless, some people rescued flaws in a CDC’s investigate methods. Feminist author Christina Hoff Sommers remarkable that a statistic would put US passionate attack on a customary with a war-torn Democratic Republic of a Congo.

She argued that a CDC investigate let a researchers conclude what counted as rape instead of a interviewees. Women who had sex while dipsomaniac though wholesome were conflated with those who had been penetrated while they were too dipsomaniac to give consent.

Instead of a 3.7 million victims identified in a CDC survey, Sommers believed that a genuine series was closer to a 188,000 rapes available by a Bureau of Justice Statistics.

5 1 In 5 Women Will Be Sexually Assaulted On Campus


In 2007, a US Department of Justice expelled their Campus Sexual Assault Study. It carried one eye-catching statistic that has spin famous: One in 5 women practice passionate attack on campus.

In a scarcely 10 years given then, other studies have reported identical findings. The latest was published in 2015 and focused on chosen universities. Using a representation distance of 150,000 students from 27 schools, this investigate seemed to endorse that a one in 5 ratio was accurate. In fact, their rate was somewhat aloft during 23 percent, that led some people to spin adult a statistic to one in 4 women.

Some critics, like Christina Hoff Sommers, contend that both of these sum are misleading. Sommers argues that such surveys humour from preference bias, where a women who respond are a ones who would have naturally clever feelings about a survey.

This could potentially askance a results. Sommers has also argued that a 2007 Campus Sexual Assault Study conflated consensual sex while dipsomaniac with nonconsensual sex while drunk, that was redefined as rape.

Others have called a one in 4 figure misleading, observant that customarily 11 percent of a women in a investigate “were assaulted in a approach that is unchanging with rapist definitions of rape or sodomy.” A many aloft commission were fondled or perceived neglected kisses, upsetting practice that competence not pass a authorised customary for passionate attack in a justice of law.

The Campus Sexual Assault Study also used a argumentative clarification of “sexual harassment.” For example, being regularly asked out to cooking after you’d pronounced “no” and being told wanton jokes that we found descent were deliberate to be incidents of passionate harassment. However, these events were released from a one in 4 attack figure.

4 Abortion Cuts Crime By 30 Percent


Abortion is an inherently argumentative topic. Still, maybe no other investigate has been utterly as argumentative as a one by Steven Levitt and John Donohue of Freakonomics fame. By examining a ancestral dump in US crime rates via a 1990s, they resolved that legalizing termination had cut all crime by adult to 30 percent.

In 1973, a Supreme Court’s preference in Roe v. Wade was a de facto legalization of abortion. Levitt and Donohue claimed that a initial organisation of babies innate after a preference reached adulthood during a same time as a conspicuous dump in a crime rate.

In addition, they found that some states had ratified termination 3 years before a Supreme Court’s decision. In these states, a decrease in rapist activity started 3 years earlier.

Finally, after termination was ratified by Roe v. Wade, crime rates forsaken neatly in states with high termination rates (where it was easier to get an abortion) while it hardly dipped in states with low termination rates (where it was harder to get an abortion). Again, a disproportion in these crime rates occurred when babies innate after a Roe v. Wade preference reached adulthood.

According to Levitt and Donohue, a judicious end was that ratified termination formula in fewer neglected children, who in spin don’t grow adult to be criminals.

Other people felt that their 30 percent figure was exaggerated. For example, dual economists during a Federal Reserve Bank of Boston found a mechanism blunder that had lopsided Levitt and Donohue’s data. By regulating a error, they found a outcome of termination on crime was reduced by half with a strange information and by two-thirds regulating some-more new data.

The Boston economists also criticized Levitt and Donohue for regulating a sum series of arrests in their comparison rather than detain rates per conduct (e.g., 5 arrests per 100,000 population). Controlling for that factor, a dual Boston economists claimed that a impact of termination on crime rates left entirely.

For their part, Levitt and Donohue deserted a claims. Levitt says that his claims were formed on a “collage of evidence” that tranquil for mixed factors and that a mechanism blunder was associated to one tiny partial of a whole picture.

3 The UK Is Five Times More Violent Than The US


The US has a many aloft murder rate than a UK. In fact, it is one of a top in a Western world. Yet many have claimed that a UK is indeed a some-more aroused society.

A 2009 news in The Telegraph found that a UK was a aroused crime collateral of Europe. When compared to America, a UK was found to be 5 times some-more violent.

In 2010, a FBI reported that there were 403 aroused crimes for any 100,000 Americans. The UK Home Office reported 1,797 offenses per 100,000 Brits, creation Britain a some-more aroused country.

These statistics have been used by gun rights advocates, who explain that difficult British gun control laws make UK adults reduction safe. The numbers have also been used by those simply meddlesome in comparing a dual nations.

However, others have found problems with a figures. In a UK, military record a many wider operation of behaviors as “offenses opposite a person,” including written attack and “causing alarm” though injury. The FBI does not lane such incidents in America. Therefore, proponents of this perspective disagree that a aroused crime rates in these countries are unfit to compare.

On a other hand, there is still justification that UK multitude is some-more aroused as a whole. In a mid-2000s, Gallup resolved from a check of 3,000 people that a UK is worse for crime than a US. In turn, a US is worse than Canada. British residents reported feeling significantly reduction protected than those of possibly of a other dual countries surveyed.

2 A Woman Earns 77 Cents For Every Dollar A Man Earns


The salary opening is a focal indicate for complicated gender activism. It is widely famous that a normal gain for full-time work uncover that women as a whole acquire 23 percent reduction than men. Nobody disputes this. The debate arises when opposite seductiveness groups try to explain this discrepancy.

The 23 percent opening does not comment for differences in occupations, positions, education, or hours worked per week. This is critical given women are some-more expected to work in professions with reduce compensate and fewer chances to progress, such as training children or psychology.

Men are some-more expected to work in rarely paid professions like engineering or high finance. Once we comment for these differences, a opening vanishes. But this is where a problem comes in.

Some groups, such as a National Organization for Women, explain that women’s career choices are shabby by a rigid, sexist culture. They disagree that women are reduction expected to work in engineering given expectations and amicable pressures force them to accept some-more “feminine” roles with reduce pay, not given they are reduction capable. While some women competence indeed make it in masculine professions, they are a exceptions.

On a other side, people like Christina Hoff Sommers disagree that American women are some of a best-educated, best-informed, and many dynamic females in a world. According to this side, it’s dismissive and during contingency with existence to explain that women are manipulated by outward army to take jobs that they don’t want. Women take on delicate careers mostly given it’s their choice, that accounts for a inequality in earnings.

1 Male And Female Suicide Rates


Across a Western world, a masculine self-murder rate is famous to be significantly aloft than a womanlike self-murder rate. In a UK, organisation are 3.5 times some-more expected to kill themselves than women. In a US, around 80 percent of all deaths by self-murder engage masculine victims. It has been called a masculine crisis. Many men’s rights groups now debate about self-murder as a masculine issue.

However, a statistics have generated some controversy. Not given people brawl that some-more organisation die from self-murder any year though given some campaigners explain that suicidal function indeed affects some-more women. It’s famous that 7 percent of women will try self-murder during their lifetimes, compared to 4 percent of men.

However, given women are some-more expected to use pills (which have an intensely low success rate) and organisation are some-more expected to use guns or wire (which have an intensely high success rate), a stats are lopsided toward masculine deaths.

According to some feminist writers, this shows that self-murder is not a masculine issue. Some have even claimed that self-murder is indeed a women’s emanate that is being misrepresented.

Campaigners on a other side disagree that this doesn’t change a fact that significantly some-more organisation die any year during their possess hands and that a genuine emanate is how organisation speak about mental health problems. As with all of these statistics, we will leave it adult to we to confirm who—if anyone—is on a right side.


Morris M. Morris is a freelance author and newly-qualified teacher, still naively anticipating to make a disproportion in his students’ lives. You can send your useful and less-than-helpful comments to his email, or revisit some of a other websites that inexplicably sinecure him.


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *